



















Wednesday, Nov 18, 2026 22:00 [IST]
Last Update: Tuesday, Nov 17, 2026 16:21 [IST]
GANGTOK,: The
High Court of Sikkim has dismissed a writ petition filed by Smriti Chettri
challenging the termination of her service as Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer,
holding that her appointment was illegal and void ab initio on multiple
grounds, including acceptance of an experience certificate after the prescribed
deadline, appointment beyond the advertised vacancy and violation of mandatory
recruitment rules.
Delivering
the judgment on November 16, Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque held that the
recruitment process, which resulted in the appointment of three candidates
against a single advertised vacancy, could not be legally sustained.
The
vacancy was advertised on November 3, 2025, with November 15, 2025, fixed as
the last date for submission of applications. The interview was scheduled for
November 19, 2025. Chettri's application was initially rejected for want of the
requisite experience certificate. However, she submitted the document on
November 18, three days after the deadline, and was subsequently permitted to
participate in the interview.
The
selection list published on November 25 included three candidates -Araprita
Das, Smriti Chettri and Ravi Eshan Tamang.
The
judgment noted that, following the interview, the then Chief Justice had
converted two posts of Lower Division Assistant-cum-Typist into posts of
Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer through a notification dated November 21, 2025.
The three candidates were subsequently selected and appointed.
However,
the Full Court, on April 21, 2026, decided to terminate Chettri's service on
the ground that her appointment was beyond the single vacancy originally
advertised. The termination order was issued on July 16, 2026.
Rejecting
the petitioner's contention that she had been selected on merit and could be
accommodated against the subsequently created vacancies, the Court relied on
the Supreme Court's judgment in Rakhi Ray and Others v. High Court of Delhi and
Others (2010) 2 SCC 637.
Quoting
the Supreme Court, the judgment reiterated that recruitment beyond the notified
vacancies amounts to denial of the constitutional rights guaranteed under
Article 14 read with Article 16(1) of the Constitution.
The
Court also found that accepting the petitioner's experience certificate after
the prescribed cut-off date effectively extended the deadline in her favour.
"The
level playing field, which is required to be maintained on the basis of the
prescribed cut-off date, has thus been breached," the judgment observed.
Another
significant ground for invalidating the selection was violation of Rule 6 of
the High Court of Sikkim (Recruitment, Conditions of Service and Conduct)
Rules, 1998. The provision requires direct recruitment to be conducted through
a competitive examination as prescribed by the Chief Justice.
The
Court held that the requirement was mandatory and could not be dispensed with
by invoking the residuary powers under Rules 14 and 19. It further observed
that selection solely through a viva-voce examination lacked the requisite
transparency and raised serious concerns regarding nepotism.
On
the question of creation of additional posts, the Court acknowledged that the
Chief Justice possesses powers under Article 229 of the Constitution to create
posts. However, it held that appointments against newly created posts required
the requisite sanction of the State Government, referring to Rule 13 of the
Sikkim Government Establishment Rules, 1974.
The
petitioner had relied on several Supreme Court judgments to argue that
administrative mistakes should not prejudice innocent employees and that
equitable considerations could protect appointments made in exceptional
circumstances. The Court, however, rejected the plea, holding that sympathy
could not legitimise an unlawful appointment.
In
strong observations concerning the administration of the High Court, the Chief
Justice noted that the case was not an isolated instance but one among other
cases involving appointments allegedly made in violation of legal requirements
over the preceding two years.
"The
High Court is the guardian of the Rule of Law. It is the last hope for the
citizens of the State in their quest for justice," the judgment observed,
emphasising that the institution must demonstrate that it is a model employer
and ensure that every appointment is made strictly in accordance with the
prescribed rules.
Expressing
concern over the impact of such appointments on institutional credibility, the
Court observed that the circumstances disclosed serious concerns of impropriety
and could undermine public confidence in the institution.
In
one of the strongest passages of the judgment, the Court stated: "Sympathy
cannot legitimize illegality, nor can any right flow from a wrong."
The
Court further remarked that the case should not be viewed merely as the
resolution of an individual dispute but should mark the beginning of
institutional introspection and renewal.
"The
faith of the people in the integrity of this institution must remain
unshaken," the judgment stated.
The
Court also noted that Chettri had previously been employed in the State
Government and that her probation in the High Court had not been declared.
Since she had not yet become a full member of the High Court service, she was
granted liberty to pursue any remedy available to her concerning her lien in
her previous employment, in accordance with law.